Skip to main content

Table 1 Species identification, molecular forms, kdr and ace-1Rfrequencies in An.gambiae s.l. collected by HLC

From: Impact of three years of large scale Indoor Residual Spraying (IRS) and Insecticide Treated Nets (ITNs) interventions on insecticide resistance in Anopheles gambiae s.l. in Benin

   

Species

Molecular forms

kdr mutation

(M form)

ace.1R mutation

(M form)

Localities

Years

N

Ag

M form

RR

RS

SS

kdr f

RR

RS

SS

ace.1 R f

Control IRS

2007

22

22

22

20

2

0

0.95a

0

0

22

0a

 

2009

21

21

21

18

3

0

0.92a

0

0

21

0a

 

2010

39

39

39

35

04

0

0.95a

0

5

34

0.06a

Adjohoun IRS

2007

74

74

74

28

34

12

0.61a

0

0

74

0a

 

2009

122

122

122

48

56

18

0.62a

0

0

122

0a

 

2010

24

24

24

21

3

0

0.94b

0

0

24

0a

Dangbo IRS

2007

150

150

150

85

59

6

0.76a

0

0

150

0a

 

2009

263

263

263

133

115

15

0.72a

0

0

263

0a

 

2010

68

68

68

65

3

0

0.98b

0

4

64

0.03b

Misserete IRS

2007

89

89

89

58

31

0

0.83a

0

0

89

0a

 

2009

129

129

129

86

35

8

0.80a

0

0

129

0a

 

2010

46

46

46

43

3

0

0.97b

0

2

44

0.02b

Sèmè IRS

2007

122

122

122

109

1

12

0.90a

0

0

122

0a

 

2009

190

190

190

143

17

30

0.80b

0

0

190

0a

 

2010

22

22

22

19

3

0

0.93a

0

6

16

0.13b

Control LLIN

2007

150

150

150

110

40

0

0.87a

0

0

150

0a

 

2009

101

101

101

90

11

0

0.95b

0

0

101

0a

 

2010

43

43

43

38

5

0

0.94b

0

0

43

0a

Adjohoun LLIN

2007

52

52

52

14

30

8

0.56a

0

0

52

0a

 

2009

24

24

24

8

16

0

0.67a

0

0

24

0a

 

2010

17

17

17

15

2

0

0.94b

0

0

17

0a

Dangbo LLIN

2007

124

124

124

66

54

4

0.75a

0

0

124

0a

 

2009

96

96

96

50

40

6

0.73a

0

0

96

0a

 

2010

58

58

58

55

3

0

0.97b

0

3

55

0.02a

Sèmè LLIN

2007

72

72

72

60

0

12

0.83a

0

0

72

0a

 

2009

44

44

44

31

12

1

0.84a

0

0

44

0a

 

2010

7

7

7

7

0

0

1a

0

0

7

0a

  1. Ag: An. gambiae; kdr f: kdr frequency; ace.1 R f: ace.1 R frequency. Numbers in the same column sharing the same superscript do not differ significantly (p > 0, 05)