Skip to main content

Table 1 The Range, Arithmetic (AM) and Geometric (GM) Mean live Dermacentor reticulatus counts, and efficacy relative to placebo at 8 hours after treatment and re-infestations for dogs treated with either a single oral dose of sarolaner or a single topical application of imidacloprid+permethrin on Day 0

From: Comparative speed of kill after treatment with Simparica(sarolaner) and Advantix®(imidacloprid + permethrin) against induced infestations of Dermacentor reticulatus on dogs

Treatment

 

Day of treatment or re-infestation

 

0

7

14

21

28

35

Placebo

Range

23 to 43

12 to 34

26 to 43

13 to 40

21 to 39

20 to 43

AM

33.8

23.5

35.8

28.4

32.4

35.4

GMc

32.4a

21.7a

34.5a

26.4a

31.2a

33.7a

Sarolaner

Range

0 to 31

6 to 21

8 to 22

12 to 27

13 to 30

12 to 33

AM

8.3

13.1

12.5

19.9

22.1

21.1

AM Efficacy (%)

75.6

44.1

65.0

30.0

31.7

40.3

GMc

3.4b

12.1b

11.6b

18.6a

20.6a

19.8b

GM Efficacy (%)

89.6

44.1

66.4

29.6

33.9

41.2

P-value vs. placebo

<0.0001

0.0157

<0.0001

0.1349

0.0766

0.0239

Imidacloprid+permethrin

Range

6 to 45

0 to 33

2 to 18

0 to 18

5 to 20

7 to 42

AM

31.9

9.9

8.9

6.9

14.3

19.5

AM Efficacy (%)

5.6

58.0

75.2

75.8

56.0

44.9

GMc

27.6a

4.2c

7.2b

4.7b

12.8b

16.8b

GM Efficacy (%)

14.6

80.6

79.0

82.0

58.9

50.2

P-value vs. placebo

0.6216

<0.0001

<0.0001

<0.0001

0.0074

0.0331

P-value vs. sarolaner

<0.0001

0.0077

0.2152

0.0005

0.1917

0.6461

  1. c Geometric means within columns with the same superscript are not significantly different (P >0.05)