Culicoides biting midges involved in transmission of haemoproteids

Background Culicoides biting midges (Diptera, Ceratopogonidae) are known vectors of avian Haemoproteus parasites. These parasites cause diseases, pathology and even mortality in birds. The diversity of biting midges in Europe is great, but only four Culicoides species are known to be vectors of avian Haemoproteus parasites. In general, our knowledge about the role of the particular Culicoides species in the transmission of Haemoproteus parasites remains insufficient. Information gaps hinder a better understanding of parasite biology and the epizootiology of parasite-caused diseases. The aim of this study was to determine new Culicoides species involved in the transmission of Haemoproteus parasites. Methods Biting midges were collected using a UV trap as well as sticky traps installed in bird nest boxes. Individual parous females were diagnosed for the presence of haemoproteids using both PCR-based and microscopic methods. Results We collected and dissected 232 parous Culicoides females from 9 species using a UV trap and 293 females from 11 species from bird nest boxes. Culicoides obsoletus was the dominant species collected using a UV trap, and Culicoides kibunensis dominated among midges collected in nest boxes. PCR-based screening showed that 5.2% of parous biting midges collected using a UV trap and 4.4% of midges collected from nest boxes were infected with avian haemosporidian parasites. Haemoproteid DNA was detected in C. kibunensis, Culicoides pictipennis, Culicoides punctatus, Culicoides segnis and Culicoides impunctatus females. The sporozoites of Haemoproteus minutus (genetic lineages hTURDUS2 and hTUPHI01) were detected in the salivary glands of two C. kibunensis females using microscopy, and this finding was confirmed by PCR. Conclusions Culicoides kibunensis was detected as a new natural vector of Haemoproteus minutus (hTURDUS2 and hTUPHI01). Haemoproteid DNA was detected in females from five Culicoides species. This study contributes to the epizootiology of avian Haemoproteus infections by specifying Culicoides species as vectors and species that are likely to be responsible for the transmission of haemoproteids in Europe.

have been performed with wild C. impunctatus showing that these are vectors of 12 different Haemoproteus species [2,12]. Experimental studies have also been performed with Culicoides nubeculosus, the only Palearctic Culicoides species maintained in laboratories [13,14], which have proved that C. nubeculosus is a vector of eight Haemoproteus species [7]. Recently, Bernotienė et al. [8] detected Haemoproteus pallidus sporozoites in wild-caught Culicoides kibunensis using both microscopy and PCR-based methods. Atkinson et al. [3] described the sporogonic development of haemoproteids to the infective stage (sporozoites) in Culicoides downesi, Culicoides bottimeri, Culicoides sphagnumensis, Culicoides edeni, Culicoides hinmani, Culicoides arboricola, Culicoides haematopotus, Culicoides knowltoni, Culicoides stilobezziodes and Culicoides crepuscularis biting midges. However, most of these biting midge species, except C. sphagnumensis, are found in North America but not Europe. Several recent studies have reported nine other Culicoides species as possible Haemoproteus vectors, but the authors used only molecular diagnosis of the parasite DNA in wild-caught insects [15][16][17][18][19][20]. Such PCR-based studies are helpful in determining ornithophagic midges but the presence of parasite DNA alone indicates only a possible vector, because PCR-based diagnostics cannot distinguish between sporozoites infective to vertebrate hosts and non-infective sporogonic stages [21]. The paucity of knowledge of the composition of Culicoides species involved in transmission of Haemoproteus parasites in the wild hinders the understanding of patterns of epizootiology [2,3,22].
The aim of this study was to identify biting midges obtained from a UV trap and bird nest boxes and to determine new species of Culicoides that could take part in the transmission of Haemoproteus parasites in the wild. Birds, the intermediate hosts of Haemoproteus parasites, are the most vulnerable to bites of Culicoides midges during the nesting and nestling care period [2]. This short and vulnerable period for the host was targeted in our study. First, we collected midges using a UV trap as described by Bernotienė et al. [8] and from bird nest boxes as described by Tomas et al. [23] and then sorted and identified parous females. Second, we dissected parous Culicoides females individually and prepared thin slides of their thorax content as salivary glands of biting midges are located in the thoraxes. Third, we applied PCR-based analysis for each collected insect to determine whether the insect was infected with Haemoproteus parasites. Finally, we used microscopy to examine thorax preparations of PCR-positive individuals to detect the presence of haemoproteid sporozoites. Detection of both sporozoites (the presence of infective parasite stage) and parasite DNA (molecular identification of the parasite) in the same insect allowed us to indicate natural vectors of pathogens. Detection of solely haemosporidian parasite DNA allowed indicating potential vectors of avian Haemoproteus parasites and required further confirmation of vector status.

Study site and collection of biting midges
Biting midges were collected using one Onderstepoort 220 V UV trap in Verkiai Regional Park (VRP) (54°45′ N, 25°17′ E), Vilnius, Lithuania, in May-July 2018. Insects were trapped at night at least once a week. The UV trap was turned on 1-2 h before sunset and was turned off 2-3 h after the sunrise. Insects were collected in a water container supplemented with a drop of liquid soap.
Biting midges were also collected from bird nest boxes according to the methodology described by Tomas et al. [23] in the Neris Regional Park (NRP), (54°50′ N 24°58′), Lithuania (May-June 2017), and at the Biological Station Rybachy (BSR) of the Zoological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences on the Curonian Spit located in the Baltic Sea (55°15′ N, 20°86′ E) in May-July 2012, 2018 and 2019. Nest boxes were attached to a tree at heights of up to 2 m (Fig. 1a). Petri dishes moistened with baby oil were temporarily fixed upside-down using doublesided sticky tape on the inside of the roofs of nest boxes (Fig. 1c). Insects flying inside the nest boxes stuck to the petri dishes and thus could be collected (Fig. 1d). Petri dishes were left overnight, as Culicoides biting midges are active at dusk [11], and were removed the next day. Petri dishes were replaced several times per week, in total 4−16 times per season (8.2 ± 4.3 on average). Seventythree nest boxes with nesting adults (Fig. 1b) or hatched nestlings of Parus major and Ficedula hypoleuca were monitored: 11 in NRP and 62 in BSR (14, 28 and 20 in 2012, 2018 and 2019, respectively). Mann-Whitney U-tests were used to compare the number of Culicoides collected in nest boxes.

Insect identification, preparation of slides and microscopic examination
Collected insects were taken to the laboratory and identified using their wing coloration and other morphological features [24][25][26]. Parous females were detected according to the presence of the readily visible burgundy pigmentation in the subcutaneous cells of the abdomen, indicating a digested blood meal prior to capture [27]. Heads and wings of females were removed to prepare mounted speciments in Euparal for the identification of Culicoides species [26].
Parous females were dissected for preparation of the thorax content as described by [2,28]; salivary glands of biting midges are located in the front part of the thorax, and therefore the infective stage of haemoproteids (sporozoites) can be found in the salivary glands of infected biting midges [2]. Briefly, insects were placed in a small drop of 0.9% normal saline, and thorax contents were removed by light pressure on the front part of the thorax using needles. Extracted salivary glands were ground and mixed with a drop of saline. Preparations were air-dried, fixed with absolute methanol and stained with 4% Giemsa [2]. The remnants of each carcass were retained for PCR to detect the DNA of haemosporidian parasites (as described below) [29][30][31]. To eliminate contamination of samples, we used a new dissecting needle for each midge. All material was studied under a binocular stereoscopic microscope (Olympus SZ × 10 and Olympus B × 43 microscope, Tokyo, Japan).

Polymerase chain reaction and sequencing
Total DNA was extracted from remnants of each individual parous midge using the ammonium acetate DNA extraction method [32].
For the detection of haemoproteids, a fragment of parasite mitochondrial DNA cytochrome b (cyt b) gene was amplified using a nested PCR protocol with outer primers HaemNFI and HaemNR3 and inner primers HaemF and HaemR2 [30,31,33,34]. Primers HaemNFI/ HaemNR3 amplify cyt b gene fragments of haemosporidians belonging to Haemoproteus, Plasmodium and Leucocytozoon, and primers HaemF/HaemR2 are specific to Haemoproteus and Plasmodium spp. To avoid false positives, we used (i) a negative control (H 2 O instead of target DNA) and (ii) a check with another set of primers: all samples positive for Haemoproteus spp. were double-checked using multiplex PCR primers [35], which amplify the DNA fragments between the 5′ end of cyt b and a non-coding region of mtDNA, which is outside of the HaemF/HaemR2 fragment.
To confirm the identification of all PCR positive for haemospordian parasites Culicoides, the standard mitochondrial DNA cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 (cox1) primers LCO1490 and HCO2198 were used [29]. Morphological identification was consistent with PCR-based identification of biting midges; obtained sequences matched corresponding sequences from the GenBank 99-100%.
DNA fragments of all PCR samples were visualized on 2% agarose gel using MidoriGreen dye (NIPPON Genetics Europe, Germany). All positive samples were sequenced using both forward and reverse primers. Sequences were edited and aligned using BioEdit software [36]. Genetic lineages of parasites were identified using the 'Basic Local Alignment Search Tool' (megablast algorithm) (NCBI BLAST, 2019 https ://blast .ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Blast .cgi), and their identification was double checked using the MalAvi database BLAST function (http://mbio-serv2 .mbioe kol. lu.se/Malav i).

Haemoproteus parasites in midges collected using a UV trap
In all, 232 parous Culicoides females were collected. We morphologically identified eight Culicoides species and one species complex, Obsoletus Complex, which contains several Culicoides species with very similar female adult morphology. Culicoides females belonging to Obsoletus Complex were the most abundant, forming up to 55% of all collected parous females (Table 1). Three parous midges were collected in May, 67 in July and 162 in June. We detected 12 Culicoides females (5.2%) PCR positive for the presence of Haemoproteus parasites. All these females were collected between the 19 and 28 June.
Microscopic examination of salivary gland preparations of PCR-positive Culicoides revealed the presence of haemoproteid sporozoites in two C. kibunensis biting midges (Fig. 2). Parasites identified in these two Culicoides were Haemoproteus minutus (genetic lineages hTURDUS2 and hTUPHI01).

Haemoproteus parasites in midges collected from bird nest boxes
In all, 293 parous Culicoides females were collected from bird nest boxes with bird nestlings: 127 in the NRP and 166 in BSR (Table 2).
Ten Culicoides species and biting midges belonging to Obsoletus Complex were determined. Culicoides kibunensis was the most abundant species in NRP (52% of all sampled midges), while Culicoides segnis and C. pictipennis dominated in BSR (37.5% and 74.7% of all sampled midges in 2012 and 2018, respectively) ( Table 2). The abundance of biting midges was very low in 2019 even though the same locality and sampling methods were used and Culicoides were collected at the same time as in 2012 and 2018 (Table 2). Culicoides kibunensis was the most abundant species (30.4%) collected in 2019.
The highest mean number of midges collected in nest boxes was in NRP (2.9 ± 1.4 [mean ± SE] insects per sampling) with maximum values being 48 biting midges per sampling in a nest box. The mean number of midges in BSR was much smaller and varied between 0.9 ± 0.2 PCR-based analysis revealed that in total 13 (4.4%) Culicoides were infected with haemosporidian parasites. The sequencing revealed the presence of Haemoproteus and Plasmodium parasites in Culicoides females. Five genetic lineages of Haemoproteus parasites were detected in biting midges belonging to four Culicoides species (Table 2): C. kibunensis (1 female); C. pictipennis (5 females); C. segnis (3 females); C. punctatus (1 female). No biting midges infected by hemosporidians were collected in 2019. Two C. kibunensis and one C. reconditus contained DNA of Plasmodium parasites (Table 2).
Microscopic examination of all ten preparations of salivary glands extracted from Haemoproteus-positive Culicoides females did not reveal the presence of sporozoites.

Discussion
The key result of our study is the detection of H. minutus sporozoites in the salivary glands of two C. kibunensis females. We also identified five Culicoides species as PCR positive for haemoproteid DNA, which may represent possible vectors of Haemoproteus parasites in our study sites. Results obtained from bird nest boxes revealed 11 Culicoides species being attracted by nesting birds. We have never obtained any Culicoides from empty nest boxes, for this reason, so we assume that insects were attracted by the presence of the birds.  kibunensis (a, b). Scale bar: 10 μm It is known that sporogony of different Haemoproteus species with recorded sporozoite stages in salivary glands can be completed in four European Culicoides species: C. impunctatus, C. nubeculosus, C. kibunensis and C. sphagnumensis [2,3,7,8,12]. Culicoides impunctatus is one of the most abundant Culicoides species in North Europe as well as in our study sites [10,11]. This species is a vector of 12 species of Haemoproteus parasites, as was proved experimentaly [12]. Midges of this Culicoides species are abundant in June in some localities, and this allows using them in experimental research [2,12]. Culicoides impunctatus used to be considered a mammalophagic species [37], but cases of ornithophagic behavior of these biting midges have been documented [12]. Our study confirms ornithophagic C. impunctatus behavior as this insect was found visiting nest boxes of breeding birds and to be infected with avian haemoproteids at our study sites (Tables 1, 2).
Culicoides nubeculosus is the only Palearctic Culicoides species cultivated in the laboratory, which has permitted experimental studies on the sporogony of several Haemoproteus spp. [7,13]. Some studies followed sporogonic development of haemoproteids till the sporozoite stage in wild C. sphagnumensis as well [3]. Culicoides kibunensis was detected as a vector of Haemoproteus pallidus (lineage hPFC1) in Lithuania, because two wild-caught individual midges of this species were detected harboring DNA as well as sporozoites of the parasite [8]. The results of our study showed that C. kibunensis is also a vector of Haemoproteus minutus because the DNA of two genetic lineages (hTURDUS2 and hTUPHI01) of this Haemoproteus parasite were detected in thoraxes of two females and sporozoites were present in salivary glands of the same insects. Haemoproteus minutus parasites are widespread in Common blackbirds Turdus merula in Europe and in our study sites [38]. This parasite is known to cause lethal disease in captive parrots in Europe [39]. Previous studies have shown that H. minutus (hTUR-DUS2) can be transmitted by wild-caught C. impunctatus [28] and laboratory-cultivated C. nubeculosus biting midges [7]. We have added C. kibunensis to the list of H. minutus vectors showing that this parasite seems to have low specificity to different Culicoides vectors. These three Culicoides species are not closely related, belonging to different Culicoides subgenera [40].
PCR-based testing of wild-caught insects for the presence of Haemoproteus DNA can be helpful to determine potential vectors of avian haemoproteids, but this method alone is insufficient to demonstrate that the insect is indeed a vector of the parasite [20]. Experimental studies indicate that avian malaria parasites can persist in non-competent insects for several weeks after initial blood meals because of the survival of ookinetes [21]. These parasites can be gained during blood meals on infected birds, and detection of parasite's DNA proves information about the preferences for vertebrate hosts of biting midges in that particular site [21]. This information can also be helpful in detecting potential vectors, which later should be experimentally proven for vector competence. According to PCR-based testing, 11 Culicoides species are known to harbor Haemoproteus parasite DNA in Europe. These are Culicoides alazanicus [42], Culicoides circumscriptus [42], C. festivipennis [8,16,41], C. impunctatus [8,20], C. kibunensis [8,17,18], C. obsoletus [8], C. pictipennis [8,18,41], C. punctatus [8,20], C. segnis [17], C. scoticus [8,18] and C. paolae [42]. We have detected avian haemosporidian parasites in biting midges belonging to five of these species (C. impunctatus, C. kibunensis, C. segnis, C. pictipennis, C. punctatus), and have now added C. reconditus to this list ( Table 2) even thought Plasmodium, not Haemoproteus, DNA was detected in the C. reconditus female. The presence of Plasmodium DNA in C. reconditus as well as in C. kibunensis suggests that females of both species feed on birds [20]. However, Culicoides do not transmit avian Plasmodium parasites, though these can be gained during a blood meal from an infected bird and can be an illustration of abortive haemosporidian development in non-susceptible hosts [21]. We detected DNA of different Haemoproteus parasites in 5.2% of parous midges collected using a UV trap and 4.4% of midges collected from nest boxes (Tables 1,  2). Haemoproteus tartakovskyi (hSISKIN1) DNA was detected in C. impunctatus, C. kibunensis and C. segnis during this investigation. DNA of this parasite has been previously detected in C. impunctatus, C. scoticus, C. obsoletus and C. kibunensis [8,20]. The sporozoites of H. tartakovskyi have been detected in salivary glands of experimentally infected C. impunctatus and C. nubeculosus [43,44]. Haemoproteus minutus (hTURDUS2, hTUPHI01) was detected in four Culicoides species [C. kibunensis, C. pictipennis, C. segnis and C. punctatus (Tables 1, 2)]. DNA of H. minutus has already been detected in 11 Culicoides species [8,16,17,20,41,42]. After successful experimental infections, C. impunctatus and C. nubeculosus were assigned as possible vectors of this parasite [7,28]. Published data indicate broad susceptibility of the C. impunctatus and C. nubeculosus biting midges to many Haemoproteus parasites [7,12] and in general show low vector specificity of the haemoproteids. However, C. nubeculosus has not been detected at our study site, and the distribution of C. impunctatus is very sporadic; therefore, other Culicoides species seem to be involved in the transmission of H. minutus and other Haemoproteus parasites.
Haemoproteus majoris (hCWT4), Haemoproteus minutus (hTURDUS2) and Haemoproteus tartakovskyi (hSISKIN1) were detected in three C. segnis females ( Table 2). Three more genetic lineages of Haemoproteus (hSYAT01, hTURDUS3, hCOLL2) were detected in the same Culicoides species using a UV trap (Table 1). Four Haemoproteus genetic lineages (hCUKI1, hTUPHI01, hCCF4 and hROFI1) were detected in C. segnis in Europe by Synek et al. [17]. Based on these data, it is likely that C. segnis could be a potentially new vector of some haemoproteids. For confirmation of vector status, detailed experiments with confirmation of complete sporogony should be performed using this biting midge species in the future.
Culicoides pictipennis females were found in nest boxes and were infected with H. minutus (hTUPHI01) ( Table 2). This species is of great interest because it is known to be ornitophagic [18,20,41,45], and it is one of the earliest Culicoides species in the spring [18] that can infect birds after arrival from overwintering places.
The possibility to take part in the transmission of parasites depends on the host preference of biting midges. Only ornithophagic species can be involved in the transmission of avian Haemoproteus parasites. The blood meal analysis of Culicoides biting midges helps to understand the interaction between the insect and the bird. During the nesting time, birds are easy targets for blood sucking insects [2], so the collection of insects from bird nest boxes can help both to determine ornithophagic insect species and to identify infected insects. Seven out of 11 Culicoides species collected in nest boxes are already known to take blood meals on birds: C. impunctatus, C. kibunensis, C. obsoletus, C. pictipennis, C. reconditus, C. segnis and C. festivipennis [12, 16-18, 22, 45, 46]. Previously assigned as mammalophagic Culicoides subfascipennis and C. pallidicornis were collected in nest boxes; thus, they likely were naturally attracted by birds in the wild [47].
Culicoides obsoletus and C. punctatus are among the most abundant biting midges in North Europe [48,49]. Thus, they should be considered for experimental research as potential vector candidates for Haemoproteus transmission. Culicoides kibunensis, C. segnis and C. pictipennis being the dominant species attacking birds, as determined in this study, were not known to be abundant at study sites on the Curonian spit. It was documented that C. impunctatus was the most dominant species in the Curonian spit and formed 82.1-99.7% of all Culicoides [11,49,50], and this species is still dominant, but only in some localities of the Curonian spit and only in June. Collection of biting midges from nest boxes showed that some dominant Culicoides species were not detected at all using other collection methods (light, netting, collection from humans) on the Curonian spit during earlier investigations [11,50]. Probably the methodology that was applied for insect collection had a crucial impact on the species composition and number of collected insects.
The method to collect biting midges from nest boxes may be of great importance not only with the target to find ornithophagic species [45] and potential vectors of avian haemoproteids, but also for biodiversity research and studies on changes of species composition and abundance of blood-sucking insects.
The diversity of Culicoides spp. in Europe is high [26], but available information about their involvement in transmission of Haemoproteus parasites is limited to a few Culicoides species. Therefore, using two collection methods, we found Culicoides species possibly involved in the transmission of haemoproteids and revealed which Culicoides species willingly take blood meals from birds. Information about Culicoides host preference and possible Haemoproteus vectors supplemented the missing information on the transmission of haemoproteids and will help to plan more detailed experimental studies on the sporogony process and untangle host-parasite interactions.

Conclusions
Our results provide information about ornithophagic Culicoides species at the study sites. Culicoides segnis, C. pictipennis and C. kibunensis, being the dominant ornithophagic species and found to be infected with Haemoproteus parasites, should be considered as possible vectors of these parasites. Culicoides kibunensis is a new natural vector of Haemoproteus minutus. These data can help to initiate detailed experimental studies on sporogony of various Haemoproteus spp. parasites with the most abundant ornithophagic biting midge species. This study contributes to epizootiology of avian Haemoproteus infections by specifying Culicoides species that likely are responsible for the transmission of haemoproteids in Europe.