Skip to main content

Table 1 Results for four-factorial significance tests (df, degree of freedom) with the independent factors species (Aedes albopictus, Culex pipiens), food regime (3 and 6 mg larva-1 food supply), larval ratio (0, 10, 15 and 20 larvae of the other species) and temperature (15, 20 and 25 °C). The dependent variables mortality (arcsin log-transformed) and female/male PT50 (log-transformed) were tested with a general linear model (ANOVA, F value) whereas the effect variables female/male abdominal length (AL), dry weight (DW) and biomass accumulation (BA) were tested with a general linearized model (normal-log model with backward removal, Wald value)

From: Larval superiority of Culex pipiens to Aedes albopictus in a replacement series experiment: prospects for coexistence in Germany

  

Mortality

Female PT50

Male PT50

Female AL

Male AL

Female DW

Male DW

Female BA

Male BA

 

df

F

P

F

P

F

P

Wald

P

Wald

P

Wald

P

Wald

P

Wald

P

Wald

P

Intercept

1

1082

<0.001

130948

<0.001

117040

<0.001

83928

<0.001

67157

<0.001

3431

<0.001

21209

<0.001

49678

<0.001

51860

<0.001

Species (S)

1

5.66

0.019

64.00

<0.001

94.01

<0.001

105.6

<0.001

10.58

0.001

562.6

<0.001

1247

<0.001

58.61

<0.001

76.22

<0.001

Food (F)

1

6.26

0.014

3.18

0.076

1.65

0.201

87.39

<0.001

15.03

<0.001

48.55

<0.001

6.20

0.013

4.99

0.026

0.15

0.699

Larval ratio (L)

3

5.20

0.002

3.55

0.016

2.55

0.058

3.23

0.358

3.66

0.301

11.36

0.010

3.75

0.289

7.24

0.065

1.39

0.708

Temperature (T)

2

39.44

<0.001

1839

<0.001

1823

<0.001

71.84

<0.001

152.74

<0.001

127.87

<0.001

79.36

<0.001

1092

<0.001

787.2

<0.001

S × F

1

4.91

0.029

0.88

0.350

15.09

<0.001

53.44

<0.001

8.53

0.003

31.08

<0.001

35.89

<0.001

11.98

0.001

17.38

<0.001

S × L

3

9.89

<0.001

0.82

0.486

1.29

0.280

7.60

0.055

4.41

0.220

14.20

0.003

13.64

0.003

3.43

0.330

3.81

0.283

F × L

3

1.04

0.377

2.34

0.076

2.34

0.076

17.62

0.001

7.57

0.056

2.67

0.445

9.20

0.027

0.44

0.932

2.01

0.570

S × T

2

0.83

0.436

54.59

<0.001

47.60

<0.001

83.33

<0.001

45.81

<0.001

70.79

<0.001

57.32

<0.001

65.30

<0.001

38.20

<0.001

F × T

2

16.80

<0.001

25.62

<0.001

25.95

<0.001

16.87

<0.001

32.41

<0.001

76.47

<0.001

73.05

<0.001

40.15

<0.001

17.68

<0.001

L × T

6

1.78

0.108

0.77

0.596

0.28

0.945

16.47

0.011

15.32

0.018

6.32

0.388

14.85

0.021

10.61

0.101

5.46

0.486

S × F × L

3

3.45

0.019

5.24

0.002

7.98

<0.001

0.75

0.861

7.66

0.053

10.92

0.012

6.41

0.093

11.04

0.011

9.35

0.025

S × F × T

2

7.58

0.001

11.66

<0.001

6.07

0.003

10.04

0.007

37.00

<0.001

46.56

<0.001

38.93

<0.001

0.47

0.791

0.99

0.610

S × L × T

6

3.32

0.005

1.76

0.112

2.33

0.036

27.13

<0.001

14.08

0.029

6.25

0.395

9.86

0.131

5.26

0.511

8.18

0.225

F × L × T

6

0.63

0.709

0.85

0.532

0.77

0.594

4.29

0.637

5.29

0.507

9.00

0.174

12.33

0.055

9.99

0.125

0.93

0.988

S × F × L × T

6

0.67

0.670

2.94

0.010

1.21

0.307

5.05

0.537

4.40

0.622

3.52

0.741

15.07

0.020

15.45

0.017

6.45

0.375