Skip to main content

Table 4 In vitro gas production culture of adult C. daubneyi. Average concentrations of ammonia, VFAs and protozoan counts observed in batch culture vessels for each treatment group after 6 and 24 h in vitro culturing time points, along with 24 h average gas production volume data

From: Polyomic tools for an emerging livestock parasite, the rumen fluke Calicophoron daubneyi; identifying shifts in rumen functionality

Item

6-hour cultures

24-hour cultures

Silage

Silage + Fluke

Fluke

Blank

F

P

SE

Silage

Silage + Fluke

Fluke

Blank

F

P

SE

Total gas volume (ml)

–

–

–

–

–

–

–

7.46

7.05

4.17

4.01

1.62

0.237

1.444

Ammonia (mmol/l)

8.09

8.18

8.56

9.74

0.5

0.691

1.081

16.65

17.23

17.56

18.25

1.68

0.224

0.515

Total VFAs (mmol/l)

82.95a

85.79a

67.55b

66.05b

32.87

<0.001

1.784

103.95a

111.82b

81.92c

77.31c

109.3

<0.001

1.601

Acetate (mmol/l)

53.11 a

54.75 a

44.43 b

43.68 b

72.24

<0.001

0.676

65.23 a

69.19 a

51.07 b

49.12 b

87.01

<0.001

1.077

Proprionate (mmol/l)

14.91 a

15.65 a

11.83 b

11.07 b

17.59

<0.001

0.538

18.44 a

21.21 b

14.90 c

12.76 d

140.77

<0.001

0.316

Butyrate (mmol/l)

10.77 ab

11.11 b

8.35 c

8.41 ac

7.53

0.004

0.541

13.68 a

14.66 a

10.80 b

10.52 b

51.98

<0.001

0.287

Others (mmol/l)

4.17 a

4.27 a

2.95 b

2.89 b

11.81

<0.001

0.219

6.60 a

6.75 a

5.14 b

4.91 b

28.48

<0.001

0.1796

Protozoans (×105/ml)

2.75

2.60

1.97

2.06

2.20

0.165

2.72 × 104

2.54a

2.26ab

1.85ab

1.60b

4.98

0.018

1.86 × 104

  1. Superscripts denote the results of post-hoc testing using Bonferroni measures with multiple comparisons in a one-way ANOVA
  2. Abbreviation: SE standard error of the mean