Skip to main content

Table 1 Bioefficacy of insecticidal fabric samples containing different doses of permethrin against Aedes aegypti and Anopheles stephensi mosquitoes in continuous exposure bioassay (improved test method) and three minutes exposure bioassay (WHO test method for LLIN)

From: Comparative evaluation of an improved test method for bioefficacy of insecticidal fabrics against dengue and malaria vectors

Sample

Permethrin dose (mg/m2)

Aedes aegypti

Anopheles stephensi

Continuous exposure mean CKDT in min

(95% CI)

Three minutes exposure

Continuous exposure mean CKDT in min

(95% CI)

Three minutes exposure

Mean KD% (95% CI)

Mean MR%

(95% CI)

Mean KD%

(95% CI)

Mean MR%

(95% CI)

A

3000

10.5a (10.0–11.0)

86c (75.8–96.2)

72c (53.3–90.7)

14.5a (13.6–15.4)

76d (64.6–87.4)

48c (39.3–56.7)

B

2280

11.4a (10.2–12.6)

74bc (59.6–88.4)

64bc (47.7–80.3)

14.8a (14.3–15.3)

68cd (54.7–81.3)

42bc (29.7–54.3)

C

1590

11.8a (10.5–13.1)

70bc (59.5–80.5)

52abc (37.4–66.6)

15.3a (13.9–16.7)

60cd (49.9–70.1)

36abc (24.6–47.4)

D

1040

12.5ab (11.7–13.3)

62bc (44.0–80.0)

46abc (26.6–65.4)

17.7ab (16.3–19.1)

44bc (27.7–60.3)

30abc (14.3–45.7)

E

590

14.8bc (14.1–15.5)

58bc (41.0–75.0)

40abc (25.7–54.3)

22bc (19.8–24.2)

26ab (12.9–39.1)

26abc (9.42–42.6)

F

380

15.8c (15.3–16.3)

48ab (33.4–62.6)

32ab (20.0–44.0)

24.5cd (22.2–26.8)

20ab (8.3–31.7)

20ab (9.88–30.1)

G

170

22.8d (20.3–25.3)

44ab (29.9–58.1)

22a (5.0–39.0)

29.7d (25.8–33.6)

12a (0–24.0)

16ab (6.22–25.8)

H

60

34.5e (33.6–35.4)

26a (15.8–36.2)

20a (4.5–35.5)

36.8e (31.9–41.7)

10a (1.2–18.8)

12a (1.55–22.5)

ANOVA

F(7, 72) = 168.8, P < 0.001

F(7, 72) = 7.15, P < 0.001

F(7, 72)= 5.21, P < 0.001

F(7, 72) = 36.7, P < 0.001

F(7, 72) = 17.4, P < 0.001

F(7, 72) = 4.17, P = 0.001

  1. Note: Means followed by the same letters in a column are not significantly different (P>0.05) in ANOVA followed by Tukey’s HSD
  2. Abbreviations: CKDT, complete knockdown time; CI, confidence interval; KD, knockdown; MR, mortality