Skip to main content

Table 2 A summary of Chi-square comparisons of study characteristics and density change categories

From: A systematic review assessing the potential for release of vector species from competition following insecticide-based population suppression of Anopheles species in Africa

Study characteristics

Number of observations within category studies (%)

Chi-square tests of independence

Category D

Category I

Category ID

Intervention type

 ITNs or LLINs

10 (30.4)

1 (100)

12 (75)

Χ2 = 11.564, df = 4, P = 0.021b

 IRS

16 (48.4)

–

1 (6.25)

 Othera

7 (21.2)

–

3 (18.75)

Insecticide type

 Pyrethroids

16 (48.5)

1 (100)

15 (93.7)

Χ2 = 10.157, df = 2, P = 0.006b*

 Non-pyrethroids

17 (51.5)

–

1 (6.3)

Insecticide resistance

 Resistance

18 (55)

1 (100)

7 (43.8)

Χ2 = 1.445, df = 2, P = 0.486b

 No resistance

15 (45)

–

9 (56.2)

Malaria transmission

 Increased transmission

2 (16)

–

1 (9)

Χ2 = 0.290, df = 1, P = 0.590c

 Decreased transmission

10 (84)

–

10 (91)

Collection methods

 Indoor

24 (72)

–

10 (55.7)

Χ2 = 5.705, df = 4, P = 0.222b

 Outdoor

3 (10)

–

3 (16.6)

 Indoor + Outdoor

6 (18)

1 (100)

5 (27.7)

  1. aPush–pull systems, hessian strips, long-lasting insecticide-treated blanket, insecticide-treated bednet plus sisal curtains, ITN plus LLIN combinations
  2. bBonferroni-adjusted P < 0.0125, n = 50
  3. cBonferroni-adjusted P < 0.016, n = 23
  4. *Represents a significant difference