Adult hookworms (Necator spp.) collected from researchers working with wild western lowland gorillas

Abstract

Background

In general, studies on the diversity of strongylid nematodes in endangered host species are complicated as material obtained by non-invasive sampling methods has limited value for generic and species identification. While egg morphology barely allows assignment to family, the morphology of cultivated infective third stage larvae provides a better resolution at the generic level but cannot be used for exact species identification. Morphology-based taxonomic approaches greatly depend on the examination of adult worms that are usually not available.

Methods

Hookworm parasites in two European researchers, who participated in gorilla research in the Central African Republic, were expelled after anthelmintic treatment to the faeces, collected and morphologically examined. A male worm discharged naturally from a wild bonobo (Pan paniscus) in Congo was also examined for comparison.

Results

Two species of Necator were identified in researchers’ faecal material: Necator americanus (Stiles, 1902) and N. gorillae Noda & Yamada, 1964; the latter species differed in having a smaller body, smaller buccal cavity and shorter spicules with spade-shaped membranes situated distally. Males of N. gorillae also possessed unusual cuticular thickenings on the dorsal side of the prebursal region of the body. These characters, shared with the male worm from the bonobo, correspond well to the description of N. gorillae described from gorillas in Congo.

Conclusions

Based on the morphology of the hookworms recovered in this study and previous molecular analyses of larvae developed from both humans and western lowland gorillas (Gorilla gorilla gorilla) from this locality, we conclude that the researchers became infected with gorilla hookworms during their stay in the field. This is the first report of infection with a Necator species other than N. americanus in humans.

Background

Strongylid nematodes are an important component of helminth communities found in large herbivorous mammals [1, 2]. In general, studies on their diversity in endangered host species are complicated as material obtained by non-invasive sampling methods has limited value for generic and species identification. While egg morphology barely allows assignment to family, the morphology of cultivated infective third stage (L3) larvae provides a better resolution at the generic level [3] but cannot be used for exact species identification. Morphology-based taxonomic approaches greatly depend on the examination of adult worms, which are mostly obtained only during necropsies and thus are lacking. As a result DNA-based taxonomy suffers from the absence of comparative sequences from well-identified individuals.

Until recently, it was believed that Necator americanus (Stiles, [4] ) is the only species of Necator parasitic in humans [5]. However, Hasegawa et al. [6] recently proved by DNA sequence analysis from infective third stage larvae raised from faecal cultures that at least two Necator spp. are shared by humans, western lowland gorillas Gorilla gorilla gorilla Savage, and central chimpanzees Pan troglodytes troglodytes Blumenbach, in the tropical forest in Dzanga Sangha Protected Areas (DSPA), Central African Republic (CAR). The L3 larvae sequenced showed morphological characteristics of Necator spp., having a distinct spear-like structure in the buccal cavity and clear transverse striations on the sheath [3]. However, it was impossible to assign the larvae to species based on their morphology. Based on the DNA sequence profile (ITS rDNA and cox1 mtDNA), one of the detected species was considered as typical N. americanus, while the taxonomic placement of the second taxon was impossible and was referred to as Necator sp.

After returning from the field survey of gorillas in DSPA (CAR), three European researchers were diagnosed with hookworm infections. DNA sequencing on the L3 larvae cultured from two of them suggested a mixed infection with N. americanus and other Necator spp. We attempted to collect the adult hookworms from their faeces after anthelmintic treatment. Here we present the morphology of the hookworms recovered as the first report of a species of Necator other than N. americanus from humans.

Methods

All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee (Ethical Commission of the Biology Centre of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic) and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.

Two researchers studying western lowland gorillas in DSPA (CAR) were coproscopically diagnosed positive for strongylid nematodes. Both were treated by albendazole (400 mg, a single dose) and all expelled faeces during and 2 days after the treatment were collected and fixed in 4 % formaldehyde solution.

Researcher A: A 23-year-old woman who spent nine months in the field in DSPA from November 2010 to August 2011. Hookworm infection was diagnosed 11 months after returning from CAR.

Researcher B: A 37-year-old woman who has repeatedly participated in DSPA field research for 2–3 month periods in 2007–2012. She was diagnosed with hookworm infection in October 2012.

Fixed faeces were washed with running tap water on piled strainers with a mesh aperture size of 2.8 mm, 1.00 mm, 0.60 mm, 0.25 mm, and 0.106 mm, respectively. The remaining residue on each strainer was transferred to a glass dish, examined under a stereomicroscope for the presence of nematodes; the worms collected were preserved in 70 % ethanol. For light microscopy examination, the nematodes were cleared in glycerol-ethanol solution by evaporation of ethanol, and mounted on glass slides with 50 % glycerol aqueous solution, or cleared in lactophenol solution. The spicules were excised from one worm using a fine needle to observe its distal ends. All measurements are based on glycerol-mounted specimens and are presented in micrometres unless indicated otherwise. Drawings are made with the aid of a Nikon drawing tube attached to a Nikon Optiphot microscope equipped with interference contrast.

Comparative material examined: a single male adult of Necator gorillae from the bonobo Pan paniscus Schwarz from Wamba, Congo, fixed in 4 % formaldehyde solution; 20 male and 20 female N. americanus adult worms from a woman in Oita, Japan already identified [7].

The specimens are deposited at the Department of Pathology and Parasitology, University of Veterinary and Pharmaceutical Sciences, Brno (Czech Republic) under accession numbers VFUNK1, VFUNB1–VFUNB16.

Results

Seventeen individuals of Necator spp. were recovered from the researcher A and a single worm was recovered from researcher B. These were identified as two species based on detailed morphological study as described below.

Morphological descriptions

Necator americanus (Stiles, [4]) from a human

[Based on two males and nine females from researcher A and one male from researcher B.]

General. Anterior extremity strongly tilted dorsally; posterior body bent ventrally. Cuticle thick, with transverse striations. Oral aperture oval. Buccal capsule well developed. Buccal collar absent. Ventral cutting plates well developed, with slightly angular free edge corner; dorsal cutting plates present. Dorsal cone supported by two subventral plates (Fig. 1a, b); oesophagus club-shaped.

Fig. 1

Cephalic end of Necator americanus (a, b) and N. gorillae (c–e). a, b, Male of N. americanus collected from a researcher, dorsal (a) and right lateral (b) views; c, Male of N. gorillae collected from a researcher, dorsal view; d, e Male of N. gorillae collected from a bonobo, dorsal (d) and right lateral (e) views

Male (n = 3). Body length 7.07–8.54 mm; width 344–390 at mid-body. Buccal capsule 106–114 × 89–99. Oesophagus 679–698 long, 134–154 wide near posterior end (n = 3). Nerve-ring 334–425 (n = 2), deirids and excretory pore 425–439 (n = 2) and 397–410, respectively, from cephalic extremity. Spicules slender, 865–975 long (corresponding to 11.6–12.9 % of worm length) with fused distal ends; one spicule forming recurved barb, the other straight, forming a spear (Fig. 2a, b). Dorsal bursal rays much shorter than laterals, diverged from each other at base, and distally bifid into unequal offshoots (Fig. 2a).

Fig. 2

Posterior extremities and distal end of spicules of the hookworms studied. a, b, Male of N. americanus collected from a researcher, left lateral view (a) and its spicule end (b) (note wrinkled dorsal cuticle in the prebursal region); c, Female of N. gorillae collected from a researcher, left lateral view; d, Male of N. gorillae collected from a researcher, right lateral view (note cuticular thickenings in the dorsal prebursal region); e, f, Male of N. gorillae collected from a researcher, left lateral view (e) (note cuticular thickenings in the dorsal prebursal region) and spicule end excised (f); g, Male of N. gorillae collected from a bonobo, with body twisted at base of bursa and inside matter with spicules extruded from the posterior end; note cuticular thickenings in the dorsal prebursal region

Female (n = 9). Body length 7.03–14.2 mm; width 299–540 at mid-body. Buccal capsule 96–123 × 83–107. Oesophagus 594–830 long, 128–154 wide near posterior end. Nerve-ring 297–585, deirids and excretory pore 311–618 and 247–618, respectively, from cephalic extremity. Vulva 2.40–5.93 mm from cephalic extremity (corresponding to 33.1–46.1 % of body length). Tail conical, pointed, lacking terminal spike, 182–274 long.

Necator gorillae Noda & Yamada, [8] from a human

[Based on five males and two females from researcher A.].

General. Resembling N. americanus but smaller. Oral aperture oval. Ventral cutting plates well developed, with round free edge corner; dorsal cutting plates often overlapped by oral aperture rim (Fig. 1c).

Male (1 entire worm and 4 fragmented worms lacking anterior body). Body length 4.88 mm (n = 1); width 285–286 at mid-body. Buccal capsule 88 × 75 (Fig. 1c). Oesophagus 514 long, 70 wide near posterior end. Fragmented worms with 7–9 cuticular thickenings on dorsal side of prebursal portion (Fig. 2d, e); entire male with greatly wrinkled cuticle in posterior body, obscuring cuticular thickenings. Spicules slender, 489–566 long (corresponding to 10.1 % of worm length) (n = 1); one spicule recurved, the other straightened distally; small spade-shaped membrane with fine lines connecting both distal ends of spicules present (Fig. 2d, e). Bursal rays thin except lateral rays; ventral rays running together along whole length; externolateral rays diverged from mediolateral rays, widely separated distally; externodorsal rays very thin, attached to posterolateral rays along nearly entire length, but distally diverged; dorsal rays thin, diverged from each other at base, and divided distally into two unequal offshoots (Fig. 2d, e).

Female (n = 2). Body length 6.00–6.19 mm; width 293–390 at mid-body. Buccal capsule 98–99 × 84–88. Oesophagus 580–585 long, 138–141 wide near posterior end. Nerve-ring, deirids and excretory pore 288–354, 170–354 and 189–278, respectively, from cephalic extremity. Vulva 2.24 mm from cephalic extremity (corresponding to 37.3 % of body length) (n = 1). Tail conical, pointed, lacking terminal spike, 169–173 long (Fig. 2c) (morphology identical with that of N. americanus).

Necator gorillae Noda & Yamada, [8] from a bonobo

Male (n = 1). Morphology identical with N. gorillae from humans (see above). Body length 7.38 mm¸ width 312 at mid-body. Buccal capsule 88 × 77 (Fig. 1d, e). Oesophagus 598 long, 122 wide. Nerve-ring, deirids and excretory pore 321, 481 and 411, respectively, from cephalic extremity. Spicules 570 long (corresponding to 7.7 % of worm length). Seven transverse cuticular thickenings present on dorsal side of prebursal portion (Fig. 2g).

Remarks

The worms identified as N. americanus in the present study were morphologically identical to N. americanus collected from a woman in Japan, including the cephalic structure and distal ends of the spicules [9, 10]. The presence of N. americanus in the same material from researcher B was previously proved by sequence analysis of DNA from L3 larvae raised by coproculture [6].

We compared the specimens of N. gorillae identified in our study with the species previously described in great apes [11, 12], i.e. N. exilidens Cummins, [13], N. congolensis Gedoelst, [12] and N. gorillae Noda & Yamada, [8]. Necator exilidens differs from the other two species in the shape of the mouth, the length of the spicules and the shape of the ventral cutting plates. Necator exilidens has spindle-shaped mouth whereas the mouth in the other two species has an ovoidal shape. The spicules of N. exilidens are also more than twice as long (1,360 μm) in comparison with those of N. congolensis and N. gorillae (both < 600 μm). All male specimens of N. gorillae recovered in our study possess spicules shorter than 600 μm with distal small spade-shaped membrane with fine lines. Ventral cutting plates of N. exilidens are round (vs angular in the other species). Because of all of these characteristics, the distinction of the present material from N. exilidens is apparent. The difference between N. congolensis and N. gorillae comprises the absence of dorsal cutting plates in N. congolenses, which are present in N. gorillae examined here. The most important aspect which distinguishes N. gorillae from other Necator spp. is the presence of prebursal dorsal cuticular thickenings; these ridges do not seem to be resulting from body constriction as the subcuticle layer showed no wrinkles. This is in sharp contrast with the almost smooth dorsal cuticle in N. americanus (Fig. 2a) and other previously described species [12]. The prebursal dorsal thickenings have been described only for N. gorillae collected from a wild western lowland gorila, which was caught in Congo, transported to Japan and died soon after arrival [8]. Additionally, the male hookworm from the comparative bonobo material shared morphological characteristics with N. gorillae (Figs. 1a, 2 g) and we assume these to be conspecific. Other morphological features and measurements of the male N. gorillae from the researcher and the bonobo also agree well with those of N. gorillae.

In the original description of N. gorillae by Noda & Yamada [8], the buccal capsule was given as 66–68 × 58–60 μm in males and 68–74 × 60–66 in females, i.e. much smaller than in the present worms identified as N. gorillae. However, the buccal cavity of the male shown in Fig. 2 in Noda & Yamada [8] measures 88 × 80 μm, i.e. almost equal to that in males of N. gorillae described here from humans and the bonobo. Finally, the morphology of the spicules of N. gorillae, as described by Noda & Yamada [8], corresponds to that observed by us in the worms identified as N. gorillae, regardless of some terminological inconsistencies.

Discussion

The species composition of Necator spp. parasitising African great apes is complex and remains unclear. Four species, i.e. Necator americanus, N. exilidens (from a chimpanzee), N. congolensis (from chimpanzees in Congo) and N. gorillae (from western lowland gorilla in Congo), have been described [4, 8, 12, 13]. The key distinguishing features of the above-mentioned species are not clear, especially those of N. exilidens, N. congolensis and N. gorillae. As the type-material of these species is not available at the present time, direct comparison with our specimens was impossible. Nevertheless, the original description of N. gorillae outlined by Noda & Yamada [8] is detailed enough to allow thorough morphological comparison as presented above.

This study is a follow up to previous work by Hasegawa et al. [6], who described the DNA sequence profile (ITS and cox1) of L3 larvae raised from stools of researchers and confirmed that researchers (and great apes) at DSPA were infected with more than one species of Necator. Initially identified Necator spp. clustered in both rDNA and mtDNA trees with N. americanus, the most common human-infecting species of Necator; this corresponds well to the presence of adult N. americanus described in our study. The present specimens of N. americanus exhibited identical morphology with those expelled from the Japanese woman [7]. It is also noteworthy that Necator sp. with ITS2 sequence closely resembling the type III previously recorded from a human in DSPA [6], was recently found in bonobo from the Congo [14].

Other genotypes/haplotype groups, dominant among larvae obtained from gorillas and chimpanzees, but present also in humans, were suggested to belong to other previously described great ape hookworm taxa i.e., N. congolensis, N. exilidens or N. gorillae [6]. Based on the morhological data obtained and presented in this manuscript, the Necator specimens, different from N. americanus and shared by researchers and gorillas at DSPA, are identified as N. gorillae. The possible synonymy of N. gorillae with N. congolensis (and possibly also with N. exilidens) cannot be ruled out, regardless of the fact, that the two latter species were described from chimpanzees. Interestingly, at the time of the original description of N. congolensis by Gedoelst [12], the bonobo has not yet been described as a distinct species. It is probable, that at least one of the two “chimpanzees” that were the source of the type-material of N. congolensis originated from Busira Region in Congo, which is, in fact, an area inhabited by bonobos.

Nematode identification has traditionally relied on morphometric data and comparison of morphological structures; morphology-based diagnostics of the nominal species should be further extended by molecular data [15]. Taxonomy is currently dealing with an explosion of sequence, genomic, proteomic and other molecular data [16]. However, the fact that the genomic sequences deposited in databases (EMBL, GenBank, etc.) sometimes refer to misidentified or unidentified organisms complicates analyses [17]. Each DNA sequence should ideally be accompanied by comprehensive identification of the specimen [17–19]. However, this is difficult to achieve with no clear taxonomic check on the name given to a sequence and usually no reference material is retained [17]. Moreover, sequences from the majority of nominal nematode taxa are missing [15]. Generally, the holotype which is declared as the ‘name-bearing’ specimen is too valuable to be ground-up for DNA isolation. Furthermore, type-specimens have often been preserved (sometimes for centuries) with fixatives prejudicial to the preservation of nucleic acid. As such, frequently, the types are absent.

The example of Necator spp. in primates and humans shows two possible options in resolving this dilemma. We can give up traditional taxonomy and rely on OTUs based on derived sequences. This approach is broadly used for avian malaria parasites [20]. Alternatively, a maximum effort should be made to collect new well-preserved material, which will be identified by experts and subsequently sequenced. The second challenging option is the only way to continue using the traditional taxonomy important for parasites such as hookworms. This will largely depend on the collaboration between laboratories, institutions, field researchers and wildlife veterinarians studying great apes and their parasites.

Conclusions

DNA sequences of L3 larvae showed plural species of Necator in both humans and great apes in the Central African Republic previously. Based on morphological analyses, we identified the adult hookworms recovered from the faeces of two researchers, in which larvae where also included and identified by Hasegawa et al. [6], as N. gorillae and N. americanus. This is the first report, supported by the morphology of adult worms, of a species of Necator other than N. americanus in humans. In order to maintain traditional nematode diagnostics we urge collection of new well-preserved adults suitable for both morphological and molecular examination.