- Open Access
Comparative analysis of the anthelmintic efficacy of European heather extracts on Teladorsagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis egg hatching and larval motility
Parasites & Vectors volume 15, Article number: 409 (2022)
Gastrointestinal nematode (GIN) control is traditionally achieved with the use of anthelmintic drugs, however due to regulations in organic farming and the rise in anthelmintic resistance, alternatives are sought after. A promising alternative is the use of bioactive plant feeding due to the presence of plant secondary metabolites (PSMs) such as proanthocyanidins (PAs). This study focussed on the perennial shrub heather (Ericaceae family), a plant rich in PAs, highly abundant across Europe and with previously demonstrated anthelmintic potential.
In vitro assays were used to investigate heather’s anthelmintic efficacy against egg hatching and larval motility. Heather samples were collected from five European countries across two seasons, and extracts were tested against two GIN species: Teladorsagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis. Polyphenol group-specific ultraperformance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry analysis was performed to identify relevant polyphenol subgroups present, including the PA concentration and size and ratio of the subunits. Partial least squares analysis was performed to associate efficacy with variation in PSM composition.
Heather extracts reduced egg hatching of both GIN species in a dose-dependent manner by up to 100%, while three extracts at the highest concentration (10 mg/ml) reduced larval motility to levels that were not significantly different from dead larvae controls. PAs, particularly the procyanidin type, and flavonol derivatives were associated with anthelmintic activity, and the particular subgroup of polyphenols associated with the efficacy was dependent on the GIN species and life stage.
Our results provide in vitro evidence that heather, a widely available plant often managed as a weed in grazing systems, has anthelmintic properties attributed to various groups of PSMs and could contribute to sustainable GIN control in ruminant production systems across Europe.
Parasitism has been identified as the main health challenge for ruminants , with gastrointestinal nematodes (GIN) demonstrating high farm prevalence across Europe, which can lead to considerable production costs and animal welfare penalties. Indeed, economic losses from parasitism have been shown on at least 50% of farms globally [2, 3], with GIN costing ruminant farming in Europe an average of €686 million per year . The prevalence of GIN in some European countries can be up to 100% on sheep farms [5, 6], and a global review reported that GIN infections in sheep resulted in negative production effects in 86% of the studies reviewed . High GIN prevalence is also shown on cattle farms, as a UK study found 89% of cattle in English and Welsh abattoirs had evidence of GIN . With the global rise of anthelmintic resistance over the past 50 years  and a move towards organic and low-input farming systems , alternative GIN control strategies are needed to replace, or complement, the use of synthetic anthelmintics. There is an increasing interest in the use of bioactive plant feeding as a sustainable GIN control method, in particular for small ruminants. Numerous in vitro studies have demonstrated the anthelmintic potential of plant extracts rich in active compounds on a range of GIN life stages. The anthelmintic activity of many bioactive plants is often attributed to proanthocyanidins (PAs; synonym: condensed tannins) [11,12,13], although other plant secondary metabolites (PSMs; also known as plant specialised metabolites), including hydrolysable tannins and flavonoids, have been implicated [14, 15]. Furthermore, studies have demonstrated that the anthelmintic activity of bioactive plants varies across different GIN species, suggesting that the efficacy may be GIN species specific [13, 16, 17].
The perennial shrub heather is highly abundant across European countries, indicating the plant’s amenability as a forage, and is rich in PAs . Previous studies have shown that Spanish heather extracts have in vitro anthelmintic effects on GIN exsheathment of infective third-stage larvae (L3), adult motility and the inhibition of egg hatching [18, 19]. The relative chemical composition of heather is known to vary between geographic location, time of year and species [11, 20,21,22]. For example, total phenolics content in heather measured in different studies ranged from 94 to 118 g tannic acid equivalent (TAE) per kilogram dry matter (DM) of heather [23,24,25], whereas total tannins content varied from 64 to 86 g TAE/kg DM [11, 23,24,25]. The impact of these variations in the chemical composition of heather on the variation in the anthelmintic efficacy observed has not yet been explored. An investigation of this relationship is important to determine whether heather can play a role as an alternative strategy for GIN control across European farming systems.
The objective of this study was to conduct a comparative analysis of the anthelmintic efficacy of Calluna vulgaris extract from samples collected in five European countries where C. vulgaris is native, across two seasons, and tested against two GIN species. As there are two equally prevalent and native species in Spain, in addition to C. vulgaris, Erica cinerea samples were also collected from Spain. It was hypothesised that the anthelmintic activity of the heather extracts would be driven by their tannin content (PAs and hydrolysable tannins), as this is generally influenced by environmental factors, including the country, season (local conditions) and plant species. It was also hypothesised that the anthelmintic activity of heather extracts will vary across GIN species and life stages.
Heather collection and drying process
Heather samples from five European countries, namely Germany, Norway, Spain, Switzerland and the UK, were collected and sent to Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC) in Edinburgh for drying and extraction processes. Heather winter samples were harvested between January and March (except for Switzerland, where due to snow at the site, the collection was completed in April) and spring samples from March to May. The same collection and processing protocols were followed at each location (for details, see Additional file 1: Text S1, Additional file 1: Figure S1). Details of collected heather samples are shown in Table 1, with environmental conditions and GPS co-ordinates at the sites of heather collection included in Additional file 2: Table S1. Upon receipt at SRUC, samples were dried at 25 °C until dry weight was reached, as determined by consecutive weighing. The dried samples were then blended into powder, wrapped in polyethene bags and aluminium foil to avoid exposure to light and stored at − 70 °C until further analysis.
Heather extraction for in vitro assays and chemical analysis
The extraction method for this protocol was adapted from Gutu . Briefly, 10 g of powdered heather was chemically macerated in 100 ml of acetone/water solution (70:30, v/v) . The solutions were continuously stirred on a magnetic stirrer at room temperature for 72 h  and then filtered through four layers of miracloth (Calbiochem®). The filtrate was centrifuged for 3 min at 4500 rpm and dried twice in a rotary evaporator to remove all water and acetone. Extracts were stored at − 20 °C until their use in in vitro testing and chemical analysis.
The methods used to chemically analyse the heather extracts are described by Malisch et al. . Tannins have been repeatedly shown to contribute to the antiparasitic effects of plants and, in addition, flavonols have been shown to positively affect the antiparasitic effect of tannins . For these reasons we focussed on these polyphenol types by using polyphenol group-specific ultraperformance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS/MS) analysis for their quantification . The extracts were lyophilised and dissolved in 1 ml of Milli-Q purified water, vortexed for 5 min and filtered through a 0.20-µm polytetrafluorethylene (PTFE) filter into UPLC vials. The sample was 1:5 diluted with water and analysed according to Engström et al. [31, 32] on an Acquity UPLC system (Waters Corp., Milford, MA, USA), interfaced to a Xevo TQ triple-quadrupole mass spectrometer with electrospray ionisation (Waters Corp.).
The GIN species used in this study are two of the most prevalent ovine GIN across European countries [5, 6, 33]: Teladorsagia circumcincta (abomasal) and Trichostrongylus colubriformis (intestinal). The GIN infective larvae were originally obtained from Moredun Research Institute, Scotland (T. circumcincta) and Toulouse Veterinary School, France (T. colubriformis) to infect donor sheep at SRUC. In total, six donor sheep were mono-specifically infected, four with 15,000 T. circumcincta L3 and two with 15,000 T. colubriformis L3, and these animals produced all the eggs and L3 used in the experiments described below.
Egg hatch assay
Fresh faecal samples were collected from the rectum of donor sheep, and the eggs were isolated with a flotation technique, previously described by Christie and Jackson , using a 1.2 g/ml sodium chloride solution. The eggs were then recovered in a water suspension and pooled within species; approximately 100–200 eggs were added into each well of a 96-well plate. For the stock solution of heather extract, 50 mg of extracted heather was dissolved in 100 µl of a 50% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) solution, along with 25% phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and 25% distilled water (dH2O). Serial dilutions of heather extracts were carried out before 6 µl of freshly prepared heather extract was then added to each well (n = 3); additional water was added if needed to make up a total volume of 300 µl. This resulted in final heather extract concentrations of 0.625, 1.25, 2.5, 5 and 10 mg/ml, respectively. Negative control wells (n = 3) contained the same volume of egg suspension together with 6 µl of 50% DMSO solution without the heather extract. The final DMSO concentrations were 1% per well for both treatment and control wells, which has previously been shown to be well tolerated by parasites [35, 36]. The assay was set up at room temperature (22 °C), and hatching was stopped at the end of a 48-h period with the addition of 20 µl of Lugol’s reagent to each well. The number of unhatched eggs and first-stage larvae (L1) per well were counted under an inverted microscope. The percentage of eggs hatched was calculated using the following equation:
Polyvinyl polypyrrolidone incubation
To investigate the contribution of tannins on the anthelmintic activity observed, a second set of egg hatch assays (EHA) was carried out using only the highest concentration of heather extract (10 mg/ml) which had been incubated with polyvinyl polypyrrolidone (PVPP). PVPP is an agent which can form complexes with tannins and thus remove their effects. Extracts were incubated overnight with PVPP at a 1:10 ratio as described in Zabré et al. , then centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 3 min; the supernatant was used as the ‘PVPP extract’. As previously described, 100–200 eggs were then placed in the wells with extracts incubated with or without PVPP; non-heather controls were also included (6 µl of 50% DMSO solution) that had also been incubated with or without PVPP at a total volume of 300 µl per well (1% DMSO per well). Treatments were carried out in triplicate and as previously described; hatching was stopped at the end of 48 h with the addition of 20 µl of Lugol’s reagent to each well.
Larval motility assay
The GIN L3 were recovered from faecal samples of the donor sheep after a 10-day incubation period at 20 °C, using the Baermann technique and stored at 4 °C before use in the assay for a maximum duration of 3 months. Real-time cell analysis (RTCA) on the xCELLigence Real Time Cell Analyser (ACEA Biosciences, Agilent Technologies, Santa Clara, CA, USA) was used to monitor larval motility. In this system, movement is detected based on electrical impedance-based signals via interdigitated microelectrodes integrated in the bottom of tissue culture E-plates (Agilent Technologies). This method has previously been used for anthelmintic drug screening and resistance monitoring  and modified by Athanasiadou et al.  to monitor and quantify plant extract efficacy. A total of 3000 L3 were placed into each well of the E-plate, and readings were taken every 15 s for 24 h to provide a baseline motility reading. After 24 h, 4 µl of the heather extracts was added into each well, making a final reaction volume of 200 µl and final DM heather extract concentration of 10 mg/ml, to match the highest concentration used in the EHA. A series of triplicate control wells were included: (i) 3000 dead L3 (previously placed for 30 min in Milton® sterilising fluid; Proctor & Gamble, Cincinnati, OH, USA); ii) 3000 L3 that were maintained alive throughout; and (iii) two sets of technical control wells without L3, but containing instead a 50% PBS solution. All control wells, except for one set of technical controls which measured the signal of solely heather extract, received 4 µl of 50% PBS after the initial 24 h, instead of heather extract. The same stock solution of heather extract which was dissolved in 50% DMSO for the EHA was used here, so additional control plates were run to demonstrate that DMSO and PBS controls had no impact on larval motility. Larval motility was monitored for a further 24-h period post heather extract or 50% PBS addition. Four experiments were run, two for T. circumcincta and two for T. colubriformis, and within each GIN species; one experiment was set to test the impact of C. vulgaris extracts as affected by country and season, and the other to test the impact of heather species and season of the Spanish samples.
Principal component analysis (PCA) was performed to summarise the variation in the polyphenol subgroup concentrations in each heather extract; PCA plots were produced using the devtools  and ggbiplot  packages in R (v 4.1.0).
Egg hatch assay
A multivariate analysis of variance (ANOVA) test with a Fisher’s protected least significant difference (LSD) multiple comparison correction was used to conduct a comparative analysis on the impact of heather extracts on egg hatching. The aim of this test was to analyse the effect of the season collected, country of origin, GIN species tested on and concentration of C. vulgaris extract on egg hatching of T. circumcincta and T. colubriformis, respectively. ANOVA was carried out to determine the impact of heather species from the Spanish samples, as well as the PVPP impact. The lethal dose of extract that inhibited 50% of egg hatching (LD50) was calculated using probit analysis. All tests were carried out using Genstat® 16th edn (2019; VSN International Ltd.).
Larval motility assay
Impedance data were processed on R (v 4.1.0) where the variability of the cell index was converted to the motility index . Motility index values for 5 h prior to the addition of the extract and the last 5 h after the addition of the extract were averaged for each well and then analysed using Genstat® 16th edn (2019; VSN International). This time window (at the end of each 24-h period) was chosen for analyses so the extract had settled and was not contributing to motility readings, and to allow time for the extract to have an impact. A one-way ANOVA was used to analyse the impact of the heather extract on larvae motility, whereas the average motility prior to the addition of the extract was used as a covariate. If the impact of the covariate was not significant (P > 0.05), it was removed from the model to prevent data being skewed. The null hypothesis was that the motility of larvae exposed to heather extract would significantly differ (P < 0.05) from that of dead larvae, but not from that of alive control larvae (P > 0.05). An additional two-way ANOVA was carried out to associate larval motility with treatment factors: season, country and heather species.
To explore which polyphenol subgroup combinations were more strongly associated with anthelmintic activity (LD50 from EHA, or motility values), we calculated partial least squares (PLS) regressions with the mixOmics package  in R (v 4.1.0). PLS models are suitable for this analysis because the correlations between the different explanatory variables (i.e. polyphenol subgroups) are considered. The number of latent variables used were determined by ‘leave-one-out’ cross-validation. Additionally, PLS models provide a variable importance in projection (VIP) score for each explanatory variable, allowing for the identification of explanatory variables more closely associated with variation in the dependent variable. Regression coefficients that indicate strength and direction of associations were also produced.
Large variation in polyphenol content was evident in heather samples
The results of the chemical analysis of the heather extracts are shown in Table 2. The polyphenol subgroups quantified in the analyses were PAs (procyanidin [PC] and prodelphinidin [PD] subunits), hydrolysable tannins (galloyl and hexahydroxydiphenoyl [HHDP] derivatives), flavonol derivatives (kaempferol, quercetin and myricetin derivatives) and quinic acid derivatives (e.g. caffeoyl quinic acids). The PAs in the studied extracts were dominated by PC subunits, with the Spanish extracts showing the highest PD:PC ratio. For many of the studied extracts, samples collected in winter had higher concentrations of the quantified polyphenol subgroups, with the exception of the samples collected in Spain. However, extracts from spring samples consistently had a higher mean degree of polymerisation (mDP) of PAs compared to winter samples from the same country.
The first two principal components of the PCA using C. vulgaris extracts explained 74.9% of the variation in the concentration of the polyphenol subgroup. There was no significant clustering of samples based on the season of collection or the country of origin, and the two replicates for each extract were similar. The PCA plot for C. vulgaris (Fig. 1) demonstrates how heather extracts vary in polyphenol subgroup concentration; for example heather extracts from Spain are seen to have the highest levels of PD subunits and HHDP derivatives, while the contents of quinic acid derivatives were highest in Swiss heather extracts collected in winter and in Norwegian heather extracts collected across both seasons.
Regarding the comparison of Spanish extracts (Fig. 2), the first two principal components of the PCA explained 93.8% of the variation in polyphenol subgroup concentration. Variations in polyphenol subgroup concentration were observed between the season of collection and the species of the heather extracts. In general, concentrations were higher in C. vulgaris extracts compared with E. cinerea extracts, although extracts from E. cinerea samples collected in spring had higher levels of PD subunits of PAs.
Heather extracts from the UK and Spain showed the highest efficacy against egg hatching
Mean egg hatching in the control wells was 97.9% (standard error [SE]: 0.59) across both GIN species. The concentration of C. vulgaris extracts interacted with season, GIN species and country as a four-way interaction (F(16, 196) = 4.95, P < 0.001). Although at C. vulgaris extract concentrations of 0.625, 1.25 (no significant difference from the control) and 10 mg/ml (all significantly different from the control) there was no difference in egg hatching across seasons or countries, concentrations of 2.5 and 5 mg/ml showed that egg hatching in C. vulgaris extracts from spring samples was significantly lower than egg hatching in extracts from winter samples. Extracts at 5 mg/ml also showed high variation in egg hatching across countries: at this concentration almost no GIN eggs exposed to extracts from the UK and Spain hatched, which was also true for T. circumcincta eggs exposed to Swiss extracts. In contrast, for the remaining countries and for Swiss extracts exposed to T. colubriformis, average hatching rates ranged between 23.4% and 47.9%. There was a significant interaction between GIN species and season (F(1, 196) = 46.57, P < 0.001), with the T. circumcincta egg-hatching percentage being lower than that for T. colubriformis egg hatching in wells where eggs were incubating in winter extracts, but similar egg hatching for both GIN was shown when eggs were incubated with spring extracts. Graphs showing the interactions are shown in Fig. 3 (T. circumcincta) and Fig. 4 (T. colubriformis) for C. vulgaris extracts. Egg-hatching percentages and P values for C. vulgaris are shown in Additional file 3: Table S2.
As shown with C. vulgaris samples above, only extracts at 2.5 and 5 mg/ml showed variation in anthelmintic efficacy for Spanish samples, and this depended on season, heather species and GIN species as a four-way interaction (F(4, 79) = 7.26, P < 0.001). Eggs exposed to extracts from winter samples at 2.5 mg/ml did not vary in hatching rate between heather species, whereas the hatching rate for spring samples was lower for eggs exposed to C. vulgaris extracts. When exposed to extracts at 5 mg/ml, a very low number of eggs hatched across all wells, except for T. colubriformis eggs exposed to E. cinerea extracts collected in winter, for which an average egg-hatching rate of 55.1% (SE 7.04) was recorded. Egg-hatching percentages and P values for the Spanish samples are shown in Additional file 3: Table S3.
LD50 values calculated from the five extract concentrations and three replicates for each heather sample ranged from 2.23 to 8.51 mg/ml, with the LD50 value dependent on the season collected, country of origin, heather species and GIN species (Table 3). The lowest LD50 values, which are indicative of higher efficacy, were found when testing C. vulgaris samples from the UK and Spain that had been collected in spring, and against T. circumcincta.
Incubation of extracts with PVPP resulted in higher levels of egg hatching compared to those incubated without PVPP (F(1, 142) = 1852.67, P < 0.001). Average hatching for eggs incubated in heather extracts at 10 mg/ml without PVPP and with PVPP was 0.87% (SE: 0.27) and 82.2% (SE: 1.87), rerspectively. Egg-hatching percentages for each extract incubated with or without PVPP are shown in Fig. 5 for tests on T. circumcincta eggs and in Fig. 6 for tests on T. colubriformis eggs.
Three winter heather extracts reduce L3 motility to the level of dead larvae
During the larval motility tests all controls (dead L3, alive L3 and technical controls) behaved as expected (Fig. 7). The variation in motility prior to the addition of C. vulgaris extract did not explain any of the variation during the addition of the extracts and, consequently, was not included in the follow-up analyses as a covariate (P > 0.05). Also, 1% DMSO did not impact on larval motility (F(1, 4) = 0.91, P = 0.393), indicating that any changes in larval motility in the treatment wells were solely attributed to the heather extract.
Our null hypothesis, that the motility of larvae exposed to heather extract is significantly different (P < 0.05) from that of the dead larvae, but not of the alive control larvae (P > 0.05), was rejected on three occasions, namely when T. circumcincta larvae were incubated in winter E. cinerea samples, and when T. colubriformis larvae were incubated in winter samples from Switzerland and Germany, respectively. In many cases, larval motility was lower in the treatment wells compared to the motility of alive control larvae, but it was still significantly different from the motility of the dead controls. The wells containing samples of C. vulgaris extracts from the UK and E. cinerea extracts from Spain, all collected in spring and tested on T. colubriformis, gave motility values that were not different from those of alive controls. These results showed a lack of any anthelmintic effect. Average larval motility values are shown in Table 4.
The two-way ANOVA showed that T. colubriformis motility was significantly affected by season, with larvae incubated in both C. vulgaris (F(1, 20) = 11.27, P = 0.003) and E. cinerea (F(1, 7) = 10.30, P = 0.015) extracts collected in winter having lower motility than those incubated in the respective extracts collected in spring. For the Spanish extracts, there was a tendency for a significant interaction of season and heather species; T. colubriformis larvae incubated in C. vulgaris spring extracts and in E. cinerea winter extracts had the lowest motility (F(1, 7) = 4.29, P = 0.077). The motility of T. circumcincta larvae tended to be affected by country (F(4, 20) = 2.47, P = 0.078), with larvae incubated in the extracts from Norway having a lower motility that those incubated in extracts from Switzerland and the UK.
PAs are not the only polyphenols associated with anthelmintic activity
The PLS analyses were performed to assess the association between the content of the polyphenol subgroup combinations quantified here and the anthelmintic activity of heather extracts, as measured by ovicidal activity (LD50). The variation in the polyphenol subgroup contents explained 66.2% and 69.1% of the variation in LD50 values for T. circumcincta and T. colubriformis, respectively. The polyphenol subgroups most importantly associated (VIP ≥ 1) with LD50 values for T. circumcincta eggs were galloyl and myricetin derivatives, and PC subunits of PAs; for T. colubriformis eggs, these were galloyl, quinic acid and kaempferol derivatives, and PC subunits of PAs (Table 5).
To determine the relationship between the variation in quantified polyphenol subgroup contents and the variation in anthelmintic activity, as measured by the reduction in motility, we included only C. vulgaris extracts in the analysis due to an insufficient number of motility readings for the E. cinerea samples. PLS analyses showed that the variation in polyphenol subgroup contents explained 41.8% and 85.0% of the variation in motility values for T. circumcincta and T. colubriformis, respectively. The polyphenol subgroups most importantly associated (VIP ≥ 1) with motility values of T. circumcincta L3 were galloyl and quercetin derivatives, and PC subunits of PAs; for T. colubriformis L3, these were derivatives of kaempferol and quinic acid (Table 6).
To the best of our knowledge this was the first study in which the anthelmintic efficacy of a shrub native to many European countries was investigated in a comprehensive and comparative manner. Within this study we characterised and quantified the anthelmintic properties of European heather and identified specific types of compounds in heather that can be associated with anthelmintic effects and which of these compounds can be specifically associated with ovicidal or motility inhibition of GIN. We observed variation in the polyphenol content of the extracts originating from the various countries. It is possible that environmental conditions at the collection sites could be contributing to this variation, including light intensity , nitrogen (N) addition  and grazing , as these factors are known to influence polyphenol content in plants. We hypothesised that the observed anthelmintic activity of the heather extracts was driven by the tannin content (PAs and hydrolysable), and this hypothesis was rejected. Variation in tannin content, in particular PC-type PAs of the heather extracts, was associated with some variation in anthelmintic activity, mainly ovicidal activity. However, we showed that other polyphenolic groups, and potentially non-polyphenolic compounds, must be responsible for part of the efficacy observed, especially for inhibition of larval motility. For example, the contents of flavonols such as kaempferol and myricetin derivatives were also closely associated with anthelmintic efficacy. We also hypothesised that the anthelmintic activity of heather extracts varies across GIN species and life stages, which was confirmed, as T. circumcincta was more susceptible than T. colubriformis, and eggs were more susceptible than larvae.
The observed variation in the combination of polyphenol subgroups quantified in the heather extracts was associated with the observed variation in ovicidal activity (LD50), explaining 66–69% of variation in LD50 values. The polyphenol subgroups shown to influence the LD50 values (VIP ≥ 1) more strongly were galloyl derivatives and PC-type PAs, plus myricetin derivatives for T. circumcincta and kaempferol and quinic acid derivatives for T. colubriformis. For both GIN species, PC-type PAs showed a moderate negative association with LD50, suggesting that PAs and in particular the PC-type are responsible for at least some anthelmintic activity. This may contradict previous evidence showing that PD-type PAs have a stronger association with anthelmintic ability compared to PC-type PAs [16, 46, 47]; however the content of PD-type PAs in the heather extracts was low (average 0.30 mg/g, SE: 0.04), and previous evidence is mainly from tests on larval stages rather than on egg hatching. Our data showed that the addition of PVPP largely reversed egg hatching inhibition, with an average hatching rate reversion of 81.31% (SE: 2.62), although PVPP is not strictly specific at binding PAs, as it can also bind to galloylated flavonoids [48, 49]. Our data are supportive of PAs being responsible for some of the anthelmintic activity observed. Previous studies have demonstrated that some flavonols can enhance anthelmintic activity by acting synergistically with PAs [14, 29, 50]; our data showed that two flavonols we analysed for, myricetin and kaempferol derivatives, had a moderate positive association with LD50 (i.e. lower efficacy). As it is unlikely that these flavonols would be improving egg hatching, an antagonistic relationship may be indicated here, which could be attributed to structural differences between the PAs and the other compounds .
Unlike the similarity in the associations between polyphenol subgroup content and LD50 values for the two GIN species, in the larval mobility test the relative abundance of the polyphenol subgroups explained 85% of the variation in T. colubriformis but only 42% of the variation in T. circumcincta. This suggests that most of the anthelmintic activity against T. circumcinta larvae could be attributed to compounds not quantified here, such as, for example, non-polyphenolic compounds; in contrast, the quantified polyphenol subgroups showed most of the anthelmintic effects against T. colubriformis larvae. In the T. colubriformis larval mobility tests, the reduced motility was moderately associated with the contents of kaempferol and quinic acid derivatives (VIP ≥ 1). Flavonoid groups, including flavonols, have been previously associated with activity on Haemonchus contortus L3 exsheathment , suggesting that the results of the present study demonstrate that these groups do show activity across other GIN species. As a combination of polyphenol subgroups showed moderate negative associations and VIP ≥ 1, this could indicate additive anthelmintic effects, although any possible synergistic effects cannot be determined by these results. In the T. circumcincta larval mobility tests, the groups more strongly associated with motility were galloyl and quercetin derivatives, and PC-type PAs.
Our findings show that susceptibility to the heather extracts was different in life stage in the two GIN species; for example, egg hatching was most affected by heather extracts from the UK and Spain and least affected by extracts from Norway, whereas T. circumcincta larval motility was mostly affected by the Norwegian extracts, although still significantly different from the dead control larvae. Teladorsagia circumcincta eggs were more susceptible to incubation in heather extracts from samples collected in winter compared to T. colubriformis eggs. The samples collected in spring also showed higher anthelmintic activity on eggs of both GIN species compared with those collected in winter, whereas when tested on T. colubriformis larvae, winter extracts lowered motility more than spring extracts. The inconsistency observed across the two in vitro assays could be indicative of the combination of polyphenol subgroups within these extracts interacting differently dependent on the life stage of the parasite. The association of polyphenol subgroups with egg hatching results was consistent for both GIN species, indicating that this activity was not species specific, although as T. circumcincta eggs were more susceptible than T. colubriformis in EHA, it appears that the interactions of these polyphenol subgroups with specific parasite proteins may be important here. This is also evident for the larval motility values as the variation that could be attributed to the polyphenol subgroups ranged from 42% for T. circumcincta larvae to 85% for T. colubriformis larvae. These results are in line with those reported in previous studies evaluating the efficacy of bioactive plant extracts on T. colubriformis and T. circumcincta, in which life stage-specific [52,53,54] and species-specific [55,56,57] susceptibility were observed.
We showed that a substantial part of the variation in anthelmintic activity was explained by changes in polyphenol subgroup content; for both life stages tested, multiple polyphenol types showed associations with the anthelmintic activity. This result supports previous evidence that polyphenol groups may interact with each other . Our results are indicative of antagonistic interactions in some cases and additive effects in others. It should be noted that not all variation in anthelmintic activity can be associated with polyphenol subgroup content in the extract; furthermore, the impact on the egg hatching was not a complete reversal to the levels of the controls following incubation of extracts with PVPP. Consequently, it should be concluded that it is likely that other polyphenols not quantified here, or even non-polyphenolic compounds, are contributing to part of the anthelmintic activity observed.
While our results showed a significant impact of heather extracts on egg hatching and infective larval motility in vitro, in vivo validation will be required prior to its potential use for parasite control in small ruminant systems. Heather supplementation in goats was associated with reduced egg output and larval establishment  when incorporated at 30% of their diet, but only reduced faecal egg counts marginally when included in the diets of parasitised sheep at 11% of their DM intake . Further investigation will be required to determine whether the active compounds present in heather will have an impact if heather is grazed by sheep. Alternatively, heather administration in the form of an extract could be another route of heather use for parasite control such as, for example, as an anthelmintic drench, as such a procedure has been demonstrated for other plants . This would be particularly relevant if naturally grazed heather would not result in sufficient intake of active compounds to achieve parasite control in vivo.
The results of this study demonstrated in vitro anthelmintic activity of heather extracts against common ovine GINs. Variation in the anthelmintic activity was associated with differences in the polyphenol subgroup contents of the extracts. Specific polyphenol subgroups within the heather extracts, such as PAs, were shown to be important when explaining variation of LD50 and larval motilities. However, it appears that the groups identified in the present study are not the only ones contributing to the anthelmintic effects. Additional investigation into the relationships between different groups of compounds, whether they have synergistic or antagonistic effects, would help to optimise the use of heather to reduce anthelmintic input in livestock production.
Availability of data and materials
A voucher specimen of the heather plant material used is stored at The Roslin Institute, Edinburgh. All data used to make conclusions are included in this published article and in the supplementary materials. The datasets used and/or analysed during the present study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Analysis of variance
Egg hatch assay
Third-stage infective larvae
- LD50 :
Lethal dose for 50% inhibition
Principal component analysis
Partial least squares
Plant secondary (or specialised) metabolites
Tannic acid equivalent
Ultraperformance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry
Variable importance in projection
Vaarst M, Padel S, Younie D, Hovi M, Sundrum A, Rymer C. Animal health challenges and veterinary aspects of organic livestock farming identified through a 3 year EU network project. Open Vet Sci J. 2008;2:111–6.
Charlier J, Thamsborg SM, Bartley DJ, Skuce PJ, Kenyon F, Geurden T, et al. Mind the gaps in research on the control of gastrointestinal nematodes of farmed ruminants and pigs. Transbound Emerg Dis. 2018;65:217–34.
Charlier J, van der Voort M, Kenyon F, Skuce P, Vercruysse J. Chasing helminths and their economic impact on farmed ruminants. Trends Parasitol. 2014;30:361–7.
Charlier J, Rinaldi L, Musella V, Ploeger HW, Chartier C, Vineer HR, et al. Initial assessment of the economic burden of major parasitic helminth infections to the ruminant livestock industry in Europe. Prev Vet Med. 2020;182:105103.
Lindqvist A, Ljungström BL, Nilsson O, Waller PJ. The dynamics, prevalence and impact of nematode infections in organically raised sheep in Sweden. Acta Vet Scand. 2001;42:377–89.
Burgess CGS, Bartley Y, Redman E, Skuce PJ, Nath M, Whitelaw F, et al. A survey of the trichostrongylid nematode species present on UK sheep farms and associated anthelmintic control practices. Vet Parasitol. 2012;189:299–307.
Mavrot F, Hertzberg H, Torgerson P. Effect of gastro-intestinal nematode infection on sheep performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Parasites Vectors. 2015;8:1–11.
Bellet C, Green MJ, Vickers M, Forbes A, Berry E, Kaler J. Ostertagia spp., rumen fluke and liver fluke single- and poly-infections in cattle: an abattoir study of prevalence and production impacts in England and Wales. Prev Vet Med. 2016;132:98–106.
Sangster NC, Cowling A, Woodgate RG. Ten events that defined anthelmintic resistance research. Trends Parasitol. 2018;34:553–63.
Willer H, Trávníček J, Meier C, Schlatter B. The world of organic agriculture: statistics and emerging trends 2021. Frick/Bonn: Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL)/IFOAM-Organics International. https://www.evidensia.eco/resources/1122/the-world-of-organic-agriculture-statistics-and-emerging-trends-2021/. Accessed 1 Nov 2021
Osoro K, Mateos-Sanz A, Frutos P, García U, Ortega-Mora LM, Ferreira LM, et al. Anthelmintic and nutritional effects of heather supplementation on Cashmere goats grazing perennial ryegrass-white clover pastures. J Anim Sci. 2007;85:861–70.
Tolera A, Khazaal K, Ørskov ER. Nutritive evaluation of some browse species. Anim Feed Sci Technol. 1997;67:181–95.
Bahuaud D, Martinez-Ortiz De Montellano C, Chauveau S, Prevot F, Torres-Acosta F, Fouraste I, et al. Effects of four tanniferous plant extracts on the in vitro exsheathment of third-stage larvae of parasitic nematodes. Parasitology. 2006;132:545–54.
Malisch CS, Salminen JP, Kölliker R, Engström MT, Suter D, Studer B, et al. Drought effects on proanthocyanidins in sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia Scop.) are dependent on the plant’s ontogenetic stage. J Agric Food Chem. 2016;64:9307–16.
Zarza-Albarrán MA, Olmedo-Juárez A, Rojo-Rubio R, Mendoza-de Gives P, González-Cortazar M, Tapia-Maruri D, et al. Galloyl flavonoids from Acacia farnesiana pods possess potent anthelmintic activity against Haemonchus contortus eggs and infective larvae. J Ethnopharmacol. 2020;249:112402.
Quijada J, Fryganas C, Ropiak HM, Ramsay A, Mueller-Harvey I, Hoste H. Anthelmintic activities against Haemonchus contortus or Trichostrongylus colubriformis from small ruminants are influenced by structural features of condensed tannins. J Agric Food Chem. 2015;63:6346–54.
Athanasiadou S, Kyriazakis I. Plant secondary metabolites: antiparasitic effects and their role in ruminant production systems. Proc Nutr Soc. 2004;63:631–9.
Moreno-Gonzalo J, Manolaraki F, Frutos P, Hervás G, Celaya R, Osoro K, et al. In vitro effect of heather (Ericaceae) extracts on different development stages of Teladorsagia circumcincta and Haemonchus contortus. Vet Parasitol. 2013;197:235–43.
Moreno-Gonzalo J, Manolaraki F, Frutos P, Hervás G, Celaya R, Osoro K, et al. In vitro effect of heather extracts on Trichostrongylus colubriformis eggs, larvae and adults. Vet Parasitol. 2013;197:586–94.
Gonzalez-Hernandez MP, Karchesy J, Starkey EE. Research observation: hydrolyzable and condensed tannins in plants of northwest Spain forests. J Range Manag. 2003;56:461–5.
Hunt AJ. The extraction of high value chemicals from heather (Calluna vulgaris). PhD thesis. York: University of York; 2006. https://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.434011.
Zhao J. The extraction of high value chemicals from heather (Calluna vulgaris) and bracken (Pteridium aquilinum). PhD thesis. York: The University of York; 2011. http://search.proquest.com/docview/304952240?accountid=27797.
Frutos P, Moreno-Gonzalo J, Hervás G, García U, Ferreira LMM, Celaya R, et al. Is the anthelmintic effect of heather supplementation to grazing goats always accompanied by anti-nutritional effects? Animal. 2008;2:1449–56.
Celaya R, Ferreira LMM, Moreno-Gonzalo J, Frutos P, Hervás G, Ferre I, et al. Effects of heather and oat supplementation on gastrointestinal nematode infections and performance of grazing Cashmere goats. Small Rumin Res. 2010;91:186–92.
Moreno-Gonzalo J, Osoro K, García U, Frutos P, Celaya R, Ferreira LMM, et al. Anthelmintic effect of heather in goats experimentally infected with Trichostrongylus colubriformis. Parasitol Res. 2014;113:693–9.
Gutu K. Bioassay-guided phytochemical study of indigenous medicinal plants of Ethiopia. PhD thesis; Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh; 2017. https://ethos.bl.uk/OrderDetails.do?uin=uk.bl.ethos.738752.
Downey MO, Hanlin RL. Comparison of ethanol and acetone mixtures for extraction of condensed tannin from grape skin. South Afr J Enol Vitic. 2010;31:154–9.
Azwanida NN. A review on the extraction methods use in medicinal plants, principle, strength and limitation. Med Aromat Plants. 2015;04:3–8.
Klongsiriwet C, Quijada J, Williams AR, Mueller-Harvey I, Williamson EM, Hoste H. Synergistic inhibition of Haemonchus contortus exsheathment by flavonoid monomers and condensed tannins. Int J Parasitol Drugs Drug Resist. 2015;5:127–34.
Salminen JP. Two-dimensional tannin fingerprints by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry offer a new dimension to plant tannin analyses and help to visualize the tannin diversity in plants. J Agric Food Chem. 2018;66:9162–71.
Engström MT, Pälijärvi M, Fryganas C, Grabber JH, Mueller-Harvey I, Salminen JP. Rapid qualitative and quantitative analyses of proanthocyanidin oligomers and polymers by UPLC-MS/MS. J Agric Food Chem. 2014;62:3390–9.
Engström MT, Pälijärvi M, Salminen JP. Rapid fingerprint analysis of plant extracts for ellagitannins, gallic acid, and quinic acid derivatives and quercetin-, kaempferol- and myricetin-based flavonol glycosides by UPLC-QqQ-MS/MS. J Agric Food Chem. 2015;63:4068–79.
Martínez-Valladares M, Geurden T, Bartram DJ, Martínez-Pérez JM, Robles-Pérez D, Bohórquez A, et al. Resistance of gastrointestinal nematodes to the most commonly used anthelmintics in sheep, cattle and horses in Spain. Vet Parasitol. 2015;211:228–33.
Christie M, Jackson F. Specific identification of strongyle eggs in small samples of sheep faeces. Res Vet Sci. 1982;32:113–7.
Boyd WA, McBride SJ, Rice JR, Snyder DW, Freedman JH. A high-throughput method for assessing chemical toxicity using a Caenorhabditis elegans reproduction assay. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2010;245:153–9.
Lem MF, Vincent KP, Josue WP, Jeannette Y, Gertrude MT, Joseph T. In vitro ovicidal and larvicidal activities of stem bark of Terminalia glaucescens (Combretaceae) against Haemonchus contortus. Am J Plant Sci. 2014;5:2859–68.
Zabré G, Kaboré A, Bayala B, Katiki LM, Costa-Júnior LM, Tamboura HH, et al. Comparison of the in vitro anthelmintic effects of Acacia nilotica and Acacia raddiana. Parasite. 2017;24:44.
Smout MJ, Kotze AC, Mccarthy JS, Loukas A. A novel high throughput assay for anthelmintic drug screening and resistance diagnosis by real-time monitoring of parasite motility. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2010;4:e885.
Athanasiadou S, Almvik M, Hellström J, Madland E, Simic N, Steinshamn H. Chemical analysis and anthelmintic activity against Teladorsagia circumcincta of Nordic bark extracts in vitro. Front Vet Sci. 2021;8:666924.
Wickham H, Hester J, Chang W. Package devtools v 2.4.2. 2021. https://github.com/r-lib/devtools. Accessed 15 Feb 2022.
Vu VQ. Package ggbiplot v 0.55. 2011. https://github.com/vqv/ggbiplot. Accessed 15 Feb 2022.
Le Cao K-A, Rohart F, Gonzalez I, Dejean S, Abadi A, Gautier B, et al. Package mixOmics v 6.10.9. 2020. https://cran.microsoft.com/snapshot/2017-09-17/web/packages/mixOmics/mixOmics.pdf. Accessed 15 Feb 2022.
Gaudio N, Balandier P, Dumas Y, Ginisty C. Growth and morphology of three forest understorey species (Calluna vulgaris, Molinia caerulea and Pteridium aquilinum) according to light availability. For Ecol Manage. 2011;261:489–98.
Hofland-Zijlstra JD, Berendse F. The effect of nutrient supply and light intensity on tannins and mycorrhizal colonisation in Dutch heathland ecosystems. Plant Ecol. 2009;201:661–75.
Hagerman AE, Robbins CT, Weerasuriya Y, Wilson TC, Mcarthur C. Tannin chemistry in relation to digestion. J Range Manag. 1992;45:57–62.
Naumann HD, Tedeschi LO, Zeller WE, Huntley NF. The role of condensed tannins in ruminant animal production: advances, limitations and future directions. Rev Bras Zootec. 2017;46:929–49.
Desrues O, Peña-Espinoza M, Hansen TVA, Enemark HL, Thamsborg SM. Anti-parasitic activity of pelleted sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia) against Ostertagia ostertagi and Cooperia oncophora in calves. Parasit Vectors. 2016;9:1–10.
Verza SG, Pavei C, Ortega GG. Study of the specificity of cross-povidone (PVPP) as binding agent in the quantification of polyphenolic compounds. J Braz Chem Soc. 2008;19:1627–33.
Barrau E, Fabre N, Fouraste I, Hoste H. Effect of bioactive compounds from Sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifolia Scop.) on the in vitro larval migration of Haemonchus contortus: role of tannins and flavonol glycosides. Parasitology. 2005;131:531–8.
Mengistu G, Hoste H, Karonen M, Salminen JP, Hendriks WH, Pellikaan WF. The in vitro anthelmintic properties of browse plant species against Haemonchus contortus is determined by the polyphenol content and composition. Vet Parasitol. 2017;237:110–6.
Escareño-Díaz S, Alonso-Díaz MA, Mendoza de Gives P, Castillo-Gallegos E, von Son-de Fernex E. Anthelmintic-like activity of polyphenolic compounds and their interactions against the cattle nematode Cooperia punctata. Vet Parasitol. 2019;274:108909.
Hounzangbe-Adote S, Fouraste I, Moutairou K, Hoste H. In vitro effects of four tropical plants on the activity and development of the parasitic nematode Trichostrongylus colubriformis. J Helminthol. 2005;79:29–33.
Tibe O, Sutherland IA, Lesperance L, Harding DRK. The effect of purified condensed tannins of forage plants from Botswana on the free-living stages of gastrointestinal nematode parasites of livestock. Vet Parasitol. 2013;197:160–7.
Al-Rofaai A, Rahman WA, Sulaiman SF, Yahaya ZS. In vitro activity of neem (Azadirachta indica) and cassava (Manihot esculenta) on three pre-parasitic stages of susceptible and resistant strains of Teladorsagia (Ostertagia) circumcincta. Vet Parasitol. 2012;188:85–92.
Molan AL, Sivakumaran S, Spencer PA, Meagher LP. Green tea flavan-3-ols and oligomeric proanthocyanidins inhibit the motility of infective larvae of Teladorsagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis in vitro. Res Vet Sci. 2004;77:239–43.
Paolini V, Fouraste I, Koste H. In vitro effects of three woody plant and sainfoin extracts on 3rd-stage larvae and adult worms of three gastrointestinal nematodes. Parasitology. 2004;129:69–77.
Athanasiadou S, Kyriazakis I, Jackson F, Coop RL. Direct anthelmintic effects of condensed tannins towards different gastrointestinal nematodes of sheep: in vitro and in vivo studies. Vet Parasitol. 2001;99:205–19.
Mueller-Harvey I, Bee G, Dohme-Meier F, Hoste H, Karonen M, Kölliker R, et al. Benefits of condensed tannins in forage legumes fed to ruminants: importance of structure, concentration, and diet composition. Crop Sci. 2019;59:861–85.
Maurer V, Holinger M, Oberhänsli T, Thüer S, Werne S, Shepherd F, et al. Heather (Calluna vulgaris) supplementation does not reduce trapping ability of Duddingtonia flagrans in faeces of Haemonchus contortus infected lambs. Vet Parasitol. 2022;302:109661.
Minho AP, Bueno ICS, Louvandini H, Jackson F, Gennari SM, Abdalla AL. Effect of Acacia molissima tannin extract on the control of gastrointestinal parasites in sheep. Anim Feed Sci Technol. 2008;147:172–81.
The initial parasite dose given to donor lambs were kindly provided by Moredun Research Institute and Toulouse Veterinary School. We would like to thank the farm staff and technicians at SRUC Easter Howgate farm for help maintaining the donor lambs. Thank you to Harry Shepherd for assistance improving the PCA plots.
This work was funded by the European Union’s Horizon 2020 initiative ‘Replacement of Contentious Inputs in Organic Farming Systems’ (RELACS) grant no. 773431. SRUC acknowledges funding from the Scottish Government.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All donor lambs were maintained in accordance with the Animal (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986. The study was approved by SRUC’s Animal Experiment Committee (SHE AE 13–2019 and SHE AE 15–2020) and performed under UK Home Office licence (P1B4DFBA5).
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Additional file 1: Text S1
. RELACS: Heather sampling protocol. Figure S1. Collection of 10 heather samples using a “W” pattern over a 10-m2 area.
Additional file 2: Table S1
. Environmental conditions at sites of heather collection.
Additional file 3: Table S2
. Average egg hatching (%) and standard deviation (SE) for C. vulgaris extracts at decreasing concentrations (n = 3). Table S3. Average egg hatching (%) and SE for Spanish heather samples at decreasing concentrations (n = 3).
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated in a credit line to the data.
About this article
Cite this article
Shepherd, F., Chylinski, C., Hutchings, M.R. et al. Comparative analysis of the anthelmintic efficacy of European heather extracts on Teladorsagia circumcincta and Trichostrongylus colubriformis egg hatching and larval motility. Parasites Vectors 15, 409 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13071-022-05531-0
- Teladorsagia circumcincta
- Trichostrongylus colubriformis
- Gastrointestinal nematode
- Condensed tannins
- Plant extracts